Person Page - 505

     Henry Clinton Butterbaugh was born on 31 July 1857 at Indiana.¹ He married Nancy Jane Fudge circa 1880.¹ Henry Clinton Butterbaugh died on 23 May 1950 at Greenville, Darke Co., OH, at age 92. He was buried in May 1950 at Twin Valley Cemetery, Gratis, Preble Co., OH, Findagrave #24701970.

     Ira Butterbaugh married Anna K. Barnhizer, daughter of Deacon Charles M. Barnhizer and Blanche B. Hildebrand, on 13 December 1905.¹

     Iva Butterbaugh was born in 1859 at Carroll Co., IL.¹ She was the daughter of Jacob F. Butterbaugh and Elizabeth Emmert.¹

     Jacob F. Butterbaugh was born in 1835.¹ He was the son of John Butterbaugh and Nancy (?)¹ Jacob F. Butterbaugh married Elizabeth Emmert, daughter of Joseph B. Emmert and Elizabeth Hershey.² Jacob F. Butterbaugh died in 1917.¹

     John Butterbaugh married Nancy (?).¹

     John Butterbaugh was born on 28 July 1798 at Franklin Co., PA. He married Nancy Jane Zug. John Butterbaugh died on 23 October 1886 at Carroll Co., IL, at age 88

Family History -- (Findagrave.com):

Son of Henry & Hannah Ulrich Puterbaugh.

109 Attend Puterbaugh-Butterbaugh Reunion August 1929

The descendants of John Butterbaugh who came to Cherry Grove township from Franklin County, Pa., in 1843, held their first reunion at Point Rock, Mr. Carroll on Sunday, Aug. 18, 1929. This reunion was sponsored by Mr. and Mrs. Forest Hawk and Mr. and Mrs. Robert Truman.

W. H. Puterbaugh of Lanark gave and address of welcome, A. B. Puterbaugh of Milledgeville then took charge of a short business meeting. It was decided to have an annual reunion of the descendants of John Butterbaugh, who were Henry B. Puterbaugh, Jacob Butterbaugh, David Puterbaugh, Samuel Butterbaugh, Martin Butterbaugh, Elizabeth (Betsy) Sheller and Mary Elliot. The meeting for next year is to be held at Point Rock Park at Mt. Carroll on the third Sunday in June. The following officers were elected for the ensuing year: President, A. B. Puterbaugh of Milledgeville; Vice President, Harry Butterbaugh, Lanark; Sec-Treas., Mrs. Catherine Lutz, Lanark. The officers appointed the following committees: Membership - Roy Butterbauugh, Lanark, Sadie Puterbaugh, Lanark, Eva Royer, Lanark. Program- Forest Hawk, Lanark, Florence Truman, Lanark, Evelyn Zuck, Lanark.

The only family with four living generations was that of Mrs. Ellen Hawk, they being Mrs. Hawk, Mrs. Cora Reeves, Mrs. Charles Dyslin and Ireta Dyslin. Frank Puterbaugh of Lanark was the oldest memeber, age 78 years, and a nine month old baby girl of the Burkholders was the youngest memeber present.

Others attending were Mr. and Mrs. H. B. Puterbaugh and family, Mr. and Mrs. Robert Truman and son, Mr. and Mrs. R. M. Hartman and son, Mr. and Mrs. Frank Puterbaugh, Mrs. Sadie Puterbauugh, Mr. and Mrs. Earl C. Burkholder and family, Mr. and Mrs. Frank Zuck, Mr. and Mrs. Leo Lutz, Mr. and Mrs. John Schoen, Mr. and Mrs. Earl Lego and daughters, R. C. Butterbaugh and daughter, Mr. and Mrs. R. F. Thomas, Donald Lower and son, Mr. and Mrs. Harry Butterbaugh and family, Mr. and Mrs. Clarence Dambman and family, Mr. and Mrs. D. H. Stitzel, Mr. and Mrs. Floyd Zuck and daughter, Mrs. Lottie Wingerd, Mrs. Albert Zuck and daughters, Mr. and Mrs. George Corbett, Mr. and Mrs. Russell Royer, Mr. and Mrs. Dave Stitzel, Miss Amanda Puterbaugh, Mrs. Earl Hower and children, Mr. and Mrs. Forest Hawk and family, Mr. and Mrs. W. H. Puterbaugh and son, all of Lanark; Mr. and Mrs. Louis B. Miller and family and Mrs. Ida Beidler, of Chadwick; Mr. and Mrs. Ben Butterbaugh, Waterloo, Ia; Mr. and Mrs. Dan Robinson, of Morrison; Mr. and Mrs. W. Harlan Puterbaugh, of Rockford, George Gunzenhouser and daughter, of Aurora; Mr. and Mrs. A. B. Puterbaugh, Mr. and Mrs. Virgil Bushman and family, Mr. and Mrs. H. E. Puterbaugh and daughter, Mr. and Mrs. W. A. Litwiller and sons, all of Milledgeville.

Contributor: Explorer (48206092)
Source: http://genealogytrails.com/ill/carroll/carrollreunionputerbaugh.html.

He was buried in October 1886 at Cherry Grove Brethren Cemetery, Lanark, Carroll Co., IL, Findagrave #92704250.

     John H. Butterbaugh was born on 3 October 1850 at Ogle Co., IL.¹ He was the son of Henry Butterbaugh and Catharine Hershey.¹ John H. Butterbaugh died on 28 September 1862 at Ogle Co., IL, at age 11.

     Joseph S. Butterbaugh was born on 5 April 1853 at Mt. Morris Twp., Ogle Co., IL.¹ He was the son of Henry Butterbaugh and Catharine Hershey.¹ Joseph S. Butterbaugh died on 26 September 1862 at Mt. Morris Twp., Ogle Co., IL, at age 9.

     Margaret Butterbaugh was born on 22 June 1916.¹ She was the daughter of Ira Butterbaugh and Anna K. Barnhizer.

     Martin Butterbaugh was born on 7 November 1860 at Mt. Morris Twp., Ogle Co., IL. He was the son of Henry Butterbaugh and Catharine Hershey. Martin Butterbaugh died on 1 October 1862 at Mt. Morris Twp., Ogle Co., IL, at age 1.

     Mary Butterbaugh was born on 14 November 1855 at Mt. Morris Twp., Ogle Co., IL.¹ She was the daughter of Henry Butterbaugh and Catharine Hershey.¹ Mary Butterbaugh married George Scott Thomas, son of Abram Thomas and Caroline C. Yontz, on 3 September 1872 at Ogle Co., IL. Mary Butterbaugh lived on 5 June 1880 at Mt. Morris Twp., Ogle Co., IL.² She died on 26 May 1881 at Ogle Co., IL, at age 25.

     Merle Butterbaugh was born on 15 September 1906.¹ He was the son of Ira Butterbaugh and Anna K. Barnhizer. Merle Butterbaugh died in December 1980 at La Verne, Los Angeles Co., CA, at age 74.²

     Myron Butterbaugh was born on 8 March 1911.¹ He was the son of Ira Butterbaugh and Anna K. Barnhizer.

     Mystie Butterbaugh was born on 8 June 1909.¹ She was the daughter of Ira Butterbaugh and Anna K. Barnhizer.

     Olive Pearl Butterbaugh was born on 17 November 1901 at Ogle Co., IL. She was the daughter of Charles Martin Butterbaugh and Nancy Dollie Miller. Olive Pearl Butterbaugh married William Boyd Stouffer, son of William Price Stouffer and Emma Haugh, in 1923. Olive Pearl Butterbaugh died in April 1975 at age 73. She was buried in April 1975 at Oakwood Cemetery, Mt. Morris, Ogle Co., IL.

     Ora Butterbaugh married William B. Plum, son of David Plum and Martha Stover, on 19 November 1900, Ceremony by Rev. John Heckman.¹

     Pearl Butterbaugh was born on 21 October 1886 at Ogle Co., IL.¹ She was the daughter of Edward Clinton Butterbaugh and Mary Ellen Bopp.¹
Note: unmarried as of 1940 census, Mt. Morris -- probably did not marry.

     Ruth Irene Butterbaugh was born on 11 November 1896 at Dallas Co., IA.¹ She was the daughter of David Martin Butterbaugh and Sarah Elizabeth Klinzman.¹ Ruth Irene Butterbaugh married Loren Spurgeon Emmert, son of Samuel E. Emmert and Amanda Jane Spurgeon, on 15 October 1919 at Dallas Co., IA. Ruth Irene Butterbaugh died on 24 October 1978 at Pinellas Co., FL, at age 81.

     Sarah Butterbaugh was born on 31 October 1838 at Franklin Co., PA.¹ She married Emanuel Stover, son of John Price Stover and Magdalina Dierdorff, on 30 December 1858.¹

     Stephen B. Butterbaugh was born on 10 October 1794 at Franklin Co., PA.¹ He married Susan B. Long. Stephen B. Butterbaugh died on 11 March 1870 at age 75.

     Wayne Butterbaugh was born on 17 December 1921.¹ He was the son of Ira Butterbaugh and Anna K. Barnhizer.

     Wilbur Butterbaugh was born on 18 November 1913.¹ He was the son of Ira Butterbaugh and Anna K. Barnhizer.

     Wilbur Fudge Butterbaugh was born on 6 October 1893 at Montgomery or Greene Co., OH, date per headstone, 1900 census shows 1894.¹ He was the son of Henry Clinton Butterbaugh and Nancy Jane Fudge.¹ Wilbur Fudge Butterbaugh married Etta Mae Semler, daughter of Charles Edward Semler and Sarah Margaret Gheen, on 31 December 1914. Wilbur Fudge Butterbaugh lived at Wright Avenue, Fairborn, Greene Co., OH. He died on 4 February 1960 at age 66. He was buried in February 1960 at New Carlisle Cemetery, New Carlisle, Clark Co., OH, Findagrave #16743014.

     Asa A. Butterfield was born in May 1825 at Maine.^1,2 He married Eliza Dryden, daughter of John Wendell Dryden and Elizabeth Isabelle Hammacher, circa 1847 at Montgomery Co. (probably), OH, Two children born to the marriage, both living as of the 1900 census.^1,2

     Celia Ann Butterfield was born on 9 January 1914 at Minnesota. She was the daughter of Charles Arthur Butterfield and May Eliza Mollins. Celia Ann Butterfield married John Lester Roberts, son of John William Roberts and Minnie Elizabeth Nye, in 1937. Celia Ann Butterfield died on 9 October 1965 at Loma Linda University Hospital, Loma Linda, San Bernardino Co., CA, at age 51. She was buried in October 1965 at Brownsville Pioneer Cemetery, Brownsville, Linn Co., OR, Findagrave #48899120.

     Charles Arthur Butterfield was born on 10 October 1883. He married May Eliza Mollins on 17 July 1907 at Caledonia, Traill Co., ND. Charles Arthur Butterfield died in April 1970 at age 86. He was buried in 1970 at Brownsville Pioneer Cemetery, Brownsville, Linn Co., OR, Findagrave #48899120.

     Elizabeth Butterfield was born circa 1858 at Dayton, Montgomery Co., OH.¹ She was the daughter of Asa A. Butterfield and Eliza Dryden.¹

     Note: Unmarried as of 1900 census. Fanny Butterfield was born circa April 1860 at Dayton, Montgomery Co., OH, 1900 census shows 1861, but she appears in the 1860 census (26 JUL) as 4 months of age.^1,2 She was the daughter of Asa A. Butterfield and Eliza Dryden.¹

     Lucy Butterfield died. She was born on 24 May 1851 at Chautauqua Co., NY. She married Jeremiah J. Starr, son of Moses Starr and Rachel Pennington, on 23 April 1868 at Vineland, NJ.

     Anna Button was the daughter of Catherina Kemper.